The Tree

The Tree
Director of Music: 
David HillAndrew NethsinghaChristopher Robinson
Organ Scholar: 
John ChallengerGlen DempseyGeorge HerbertJames Anderson-Besant
Release date: 
November 2021
  • Yale Schola Cantorum
  • Former Members and Friends of the College Choir
  • Jack Ross (trumpet)
  • John Clapham (tenor)
  • James Adams, Bradley Smith (bass)
Record label: 
Catalogue number: 

We celebrate the rich heritage of the choir through a new album The Tree, featuring live recordings from St John's College Chapel.

The album plays with the idea of growth, inspired by the tree described in the Book of Job, starting with the single treble line of Hildegard of Bingen's O pastor animarum before gradually adding organ, lower voices, a second choir, 150 additional singers, and finally combining nearly 500 voices together. The image of a tree sprouting new branches can be seen as a metaphor for revival in the wake of the pandemic, the textural growth of the music form a single melodic line reflecting the heritage of the choir itself.

Andrew Nethsingha, Director of Music, said “Several pieces on the album are directed by my predecessors, Christopher Robinson and David Hill. The album is released as a tribute to them, celebrating their 85th and 65th birthdays respectively. Some of my most moving and inspiring experiences in Cambridge have been watching them return to conduct the present choir. In an interview with Martin Cullingford for Gramophone fifteen years ago, David spoke of ‘a process of osmosis really. They pass on – in a way that they don’t even talk about, no one ever discusses it – a tradition of how to phrase, a tradition of how to sing a particular thing. Listen to the choir from 20 years ago, and go into the building now, and you will hear that they’re two Burgundies from the same valley, probably on the same chalk, but tasting slightly different.’ Well, I do talk about it to the choir, but in other respects I hope that what David said is still true! Alternatively, one might think of the choir itself as a tree, constantly growing new branches. My hope is that listeners might feel the ‘liveness’ of these archive recordings more than compensates for the lack of studio conditions. As I completed work on the album, pandemic restrictions only allowed us to sing services in an empty Chapel; we should never take for granted the joy of having a real (if occasionally noisy!) congregation with whom to share our music-making.”

Some works on the album are directed by past St John’s Directors of Music Christopher Robinson and David Hill and it features music by St John’s Composers including Robinson, Herbert Howells and Jonathan Harvey. The album also features sicut aquilae by James Long, one of the five works written for the College’s 500th anniversary. Nethsingha has paired these works with music by Elgar, Rowlands, Parry, Stainer and Stanford all dating from around the turn of the twentieth century.

All tracks on the album are taken from live services in the St John’s College Chapel, including an Evensong where the choir performed with Yale Schola Cantorum in addition to tracks from a special alumni service in 2019 where generations of former choir members came together to celebrate the 150th anniversary of the College Chapel. The album concludes with Love Divine, all loves excelling, sung by nearly 500 people including the choir, former choir members and the congregation.

Track list

  1. O pastor animarum - Hildegard of Bingen (1098-1179)
  2. The Tree - Jonathan Harvey (1939-2012)
  3. sicut aquilae - James Long (b.1987)
  4. The Preces - Herbert Howells (1892-1983)
  5. The Responses - Herbert Howells
  6. The Spirit of the Lord - Edward Elgar (1857-1934)
  7. A Hymn for St. Cecilia - Herbert Howells
  8. A Song of Wisdom - Charles Villiers Stanford (1852-1924)
  9. Jesu, grant me this, I pray - Christopher Robinson (b.1936)
  10. Hear my words, ye people - Charles Hubert Hastings Parry (1848-1918)
  11. God so loved the world - John Stainer (1840-1901)
  12. Hymn - Love Divine, all loves excelling - Tune: Blaenwern, William Rowlands (1860-1937). Descant: Christopher Robinson)



‘A Song of Wisdom’, one of [Stanford’s] six Bible Songs, is given one of those performances to which you want to keep returning. It’s not just Andrew Nethsingha’s controlled shaping of musical paragraphs that attract the ear, it is the eager and exultant tone from the boys. They so obviously relish Stanford’s soaring lines and climaxes, none more thrilling than at ‘Come unto me’, the top B-flat resounding gloriously. For me, it’s the highlight of the disc.

David Truslove, Opera Today

This is another very fine album from the Choir of St John’s College, Cambridge. Though the performances were recorded over several years and at different services, the standard of singing – and organ playing – is consistent, which is to say excellent
★★★★★ The outstanding quality of the singing and playing is the reason to buy this recording. Even something as straightforward as Stanford's 'A song of Wisdom' is given a ravishing performance

Clare Stevens, Choir & Organ

The whole thing is a beautifully realised tribute to the history of the choir and its hope for the future

Andrew McGregor, BBC Radio 3 Record Review

Andrew Nethsingha is explicit in his eloquent booklet essay that this latest well-crafted and beautifully sung disc from the Choir of St John's College, Cambridge is about rebuilding 'after pandemic and political upheaval'

Christopher Dingle, BBC Music Magazine

This listener is always pleased to hear Edward Elgar's 'The Spirit of the Lord', particularly when it is sung as well as it is here and likewise 'A Hymn for St Cecilia' by Herbert Howells is always a joy

Steven Whitehead, Cross Rhythms

The trebles make a splendid impact in Jonathan Harvey's 'The Tree', a piece glinting with light

Richard Fairman, Financial Times

Overall, the recording leaves the listener full of admiration for all aspects of this compilation, which is exceptionally well balanced technically. However, perhaps a medal should be awarded to the trebles for their highly sensitive and superb performance of Stanford's 'Song of Wisdom' which is, without doubt, one of the highlights of a most inspiring disc

David Thorne, Cathedral Music Magazine

Share this

Latest webcast

Recorded on
9 March 2024


A Meditation on the Passion of Christ is a service of music and readings reflecting on the Passion of Christ. This year the service features music by Byrd, Purcell, Weelkes and MacMillan, as well as the final piece of a triptych of works written for the choir by Joanna Marsh.

Latest news

Magnificat 4 includes two commissions written specially for the Choir of St John's College; Jonathan Dove's 2022 canticle setting St John's Service, and Judith Weir's 2011 service of the same name.

Winner of the 2008 Ivor Novello Award for classical music, Jonathan Dove CBE has composed a broad range of works and is one of the most successful British composers today. 

Jonathan was kind enough to share insights into his St John's Service, the compositional process, and what we can look forward to in the future.

The commitment, projection and natural energy of this choir have never failed to inspire me

Organists’ Review